Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Vinyl > Digital on HowStuffWorks, Is their explanation incorrect?
post Feb 16 2009, 00:36
Post #1

Group: Members
Posts: 1
Joined: 16-February 09
Member No.: 67032

My friend won't give in that he just likes the motions of putting his records on his turntable but he found this website:


This means that the waveforms from a vinyl recording can be much more accurate, and that can be heard in the richness of the sound.

From the graph above you can see that CD quality audio does not do a very good job of replicating the original signal. (at 16/44.1)

I referred him to this:


I'm trying to understand the specifics but I'm a little lost. Are these two contradictory? Could someone clear up where HowStuffWorks might be disseminating wrong info?

This post has been edited by Peter: Feb 19 2009, 02:32
Reason for edit: Link now less search engine friendly.
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Start new topic
post Mar 3 2009, 21:24
Post #2

Group: Members
Posts: 835
Joined: 17-September 06
Member No.: 35307

Sorry to resurrect an oldish topic, but OMG!

I've just googled for...
Vinyl versus CD

Top link is to http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=375592 - a Google Answers response which I didn't provide a proper link to for fear of improving its Google rating - and is completely misguided or patently false. All responses are pretty old (2004).

If you wanted to know the objectivist right answer, you're unlikely to search for Vinyl myths and would struggle to come across Hydrogen Audio's rational, sound reasoning (no pun intended) that CD is superior to Vinyl as a delivery format to human listening as long as one sticks to the rules.

The rules include pre-filtering to avoid aliasing below the Nyquist frequency, quantization with appropriate dither and reconstruction with appropriate reconstruction filtering (whether done by analogue filters or oversampling).

The google search...
LP vinyl compare CD
...isn't much better and the same Google Answers result is now second highest.

Is CD better than LP?
...is a poor search
Is CD better than vinyl?
...provides a better second link, Audio myth: Vinyl better than CD? | Audio DesignLine

A myth so popular is hard to supercede in terms of answer-finding, and SearchWiki appears to be pretty-much useless to warn people of false information.

From a blind testing perspective, it's possible make a demonstration by means of properly digitising a good Vinyl source, that the analogue sound and its digitial reproduction are indisinguishable to the human ear. I'm pretty sure Pio2001 spent a lot of time doing this and reporting his results on Hydrogen Audio some years ago. Therefore, even if pops and crackles, hiss etc are desired, they can be transparently reproduced on CD.

An example is to feed an analogue source of any quality we choose in case A, directly to the amplifier, or in case B, via a good properly filtered ADC and DAC at CD specifications (i.e. at some stage, the digital signal must be reduced to 44.1kHz, 16-bit per channel with proper dither) and then to the amplifier. Switching in (case B) and out (case A) the digital stage one can attempt to determine whether or not the digital stage is transparent (subject to negligible delay). If the switch position is kept secret to the experimental participants, we have an ABX test. We could even use a repeating loop of studio magnetic tape with a suitably high tape speed that should satisfy the most stringent analogue enthusiasts.
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
- snoozer   Vinyl > Digital on HowStuffWorks   Feb 16 2009, 00:36
- - Mike Giacomelli   QUOTE (snoozer @ Feb 15 2009, 18:36) I...   Feb 16 2009, 01:03
- - Canar   It is completely, horribly wrong, down to the grap...   Feb 16 2009, 01:22
- - Axon   Here's what I put down on the contact us page....   Feb 16 2009, 08:51
|- - krabapple   QUOTE (Axon @ Feb 16 2009, 02:51) This is...   Feb 18 2009, 18:35
|- - Axon   QUOTE (krabapple @ Feb 18 2009, 11:35) QU...   Feb 18 2009, 19:19
- - DVDdoug   QUOTE The waveform is a lie (CDs do not output squ...   Feb 17 2009, 20:51
- - AndyH-ha   Perhaps these have exceptionally low cost soundcar...   Feb 17 2009, 21:51
|- - krabapple   QUOTE (AndyH-ha @ Feb 17 2009, 15:51...   Feb 18 2009, 18:37
- - greynol   Well, there's gotta be a DAC, but it appears t...   Feb 17 2009, 22:19
- - Axon   If it really does look like that then it will have...   Feb 18 2009, 02:19
|- - greynol   QUOTE (Axon @ Feb 17 2009, 17:19) If it r...   Feb 18 2009, 02:52
- - Axon   Lavry's sampling paper goes over inherent atte...   Feb 18 2009, 03:09
- - seangan   There are two things you can tell your friend. Fir...   Feb 18 2009, 03:25
|- - krabapple   QUOTE (seangan @ Feb 17 2009, 21:25) Iím ...   Feb 18 2009, 18:39
- - greynol   That's an informative paper, Axon. Thanks...   Feb 18 2009, 03:27
- - 2Bdecided   Can't we break the link in the first post? I d...   Feb 18 2009, 11:39
- - DVDdoug   QUOTE Doug, can you please dig into your work comp...   Feb 18 2009, 22:15
|- - Arnold B. Krueger   QUOTE (DVDdoug @ Feb 18 2009, 16:15) QUOT...   Feb 24 2009, 22:05
- - Axon   Those are some pretty common cards. I did not expe...   Feb 18 2009, 23:02
- - Dynamic   Sorry to resurrect an oldish topic, but OMG! ...   Mar 3 2009, 21:24
- - Axon   There was a blind test conducted by a bunch of Vin...   Mar 3 2009, 22:00
- - Knowzy   QUOTE (Axon @ Feb 18 2009, 10:19) Mods: i...   Mar 4 2009, 19:53
- - TomasPin   Bumping this to report that article is still aroun...   Aug 5 2013, 23:20
- - AliceWonder   That article made me very angry. It brought up mem...   Mar 21 2014, 12:45
- - andy o   A lot of (all?) pseudosciences are very similar in...   Mar 21 2014, 16:57
- - polemon   QUOTE This means that, by definition, a digital re...   Mar 22 2014, 02:14
- - yourlord   Any time you come across crap like this, just link...   Mar 22 2014, 03:50
- - Glenn Gundlach   QUOTE (yourlord @ Mar 21 2014, 18:50) Any...   Mar 22 2014, 21:51

Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:


RSS Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 1st December 2015 - 02:56