Skip to main content ↑ ↓

Notice

Please note that most of the software linked on this forum is likely to be safe to use. If you are unsure, feel free to ask in the relevant topics, or send a private message to an administrator or moderator. To help curb the problems of false positives, or in the event that you do find actual malware, you can contribute through the article linked here.
Topic: EAC: The external compressor returned an error! (Read 16638 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Hi guys.

My first post!

I signed up hoping someone may be able to help me since the search funtion on this forum is totally useless!  When trying to search for the phrase"The external compressor returned an error" the error returned was:
Quote
One or all of your search keywords were below 4 characters or you are searched for words which are not allowed, such as 'html', 'img', etc, please go back and increase the length of these search keywords or choose different keywords.

Anyway, I am trying to use the guide http://users.pandora.be/satcp/eac-qs-en.htm to setup EAC 0.95b3 & LAME 3.97 beta 2 (I can't find beta 1).

EAC is displaying this error message after any attempt at compressing a wav.
---------------------------
Warning
---------------------------
The external compressor returned an error!

Options : -V 2 --vbr-new --add-id3v2 --pad-id3v2 --ta "Sun Don't Shine In The Hood" --tt "The Furious Five" --tl "Raiders Of The Lost Art" --ty "" --tn "02" "C:\Playlist\Raiders Of The Lost Art ()\0tmp660-!.wav" "C:\Playlist\Raiders Of The Lost Art ()\0tmp660-!.mp3"

File : C:\Playlist\Raiders Of The Lost Art ()\02. Sun Don't Shine In The Hood - The Furious Five.wav
---------------------------
OK 
---------------------------

I've been working on this for a whole day.  I do like a challenge but I also like spending my time wisely!

Thanx 4 looking.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #1 –
Weclome, skywalka!

Maybe lame tagging is getting in the way of EAC tagging.

Your lame options show that it is adding the id3 tags, so maybe unchecking the id3 tags options in EAC (both in the "external compressor" and "ID3 Tag" tabs) will do the trick.

Alternitavely, you could make your lame options into
Code: [Select]
-V 2 --vbr-new %s %d
and let EAC do the id3v1 and v2 tagging by leaving those boxes checked.

That's just my first guess.  If that doesn't work the real experts will answer you soon enough  .

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #2 –
Quote
...the search funtion on this forum is totally useless!  When trying to search for the phrase"The external compressor returned an error" the error returned was:
Quote
One or all of your search keywords were below 4 characters or you are searched for words which are not allowed, such as 'html', 'img', etc, please go back and increase the length of these search keywords or choose different keywords.
How can you possibly claim that the search function is "useless", when it:
(a) told you exactly what the problem with your input was, and
(b) told you exactly how to fix it

All you had to do was omit the words "the" and "an" from your search string.

Maybe it's you that's coming across a bit useless.

Regards,
Madrigal

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #3 –
Quote
Quote
...the search funtion on this forum is totally useless!  When trying to search for the phrase"The external compressor returned an error" the error returned was:
Quote
One or all of your search keywords were below 4 characters or you are searched for words which are not allowed, such as 'html', 'img', etc, please go back and increase the length of these search keywords or choose different keywords.
How can you possibly claim that the search function is "useless", when it:
(a) told you exactly what the problem with your input was, and
(b) told you exactly how to fix it

All you had to do was omit the words "the" and "an" from your search string.

Maybe it's you that's coming across a bit useless.

Regards,
Madrigal
[a href="index.php?act=findpost&pid=354715"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
The length of a word isn't neccesarily proportional to it's relevance.  So, words like CPU, ATA or IDE should be able to be searched but can't be.

Anyway, because I was searching for an exact phrase by using quotation marks it is imperative that all words within that phrase can be searched.

So while the error message did inform me of the problem, there is no way to fix it because I am not the forum software designer.

So please, either tell me how to search for the exact phrase or, in future, try to refrain from hijacking my thread with your USELESS timewasting.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #4 –
Quote
Weclome, skywalka!

Maybe lame tagging is getting in the way of EAC tagging.

Your lame options show that it is adding the id3 tags, so maybe unchecking the id3 tags options in EAC (both in the "external compressor" and "ID3 Tag" tabs) will do the trick.

Alternitavely, you could make your lame options into
Code: [Select]
-V 2 --vbr-new %s %d
and let EAC do the id3v1 and v2 tagging by leaving those boxes checked.

That's just my first guess.  If that doesn't work the real experts will answer you soon enough  .
[a href="index.php?act=findpost&pid=354714"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Hi hyper84.

Thanx 4 your help.

I did have all those mp3 tagging options unchecked.  It was stipulated in the guide I was following.

I tried the method you suggested also but to no avail.

Thanx anyway.

I probably should have mentioned above that when it comes time to compress the files it appears a DOS box is being opened but closing straight away.  I can't see any text within this box but this could be due to lag on my video card or memory.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #5 –
It may be useful if you post (in text) what "Additional command line options" you're using in EAC.

Something like this is valid:
-V 2 --vbr-new %s %d

This however isn't because it's missing %s (source) %d (destination) at the end:
-V 2 --vbr-new

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #6 –
Quote
It may be useful if you post (in text) what "Additional command line options" you're using in EAC.

Something like this is valid:
-V 2 --vbr-new %s %d

This however isn't because it's missing %s (source) %d (destination) at the end:
-V 2 --vbr-new
[a href="index.php?act=findpost&pid=354738"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Oops!

Yeah I should have because there are different options on that page.  I am using the recommended settings.

-V 2 --vbr-new --add-id3v2 --pad-id3v2 --ta "%a" --tt "%t" --tl "%g" --ty "%y" --tn "%n" %s %d

Thanx 4 your help.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #7 –
I don't know what to tell you.  I just tried:
Code: [Select]
-V 2 --vbr-new %s %d
and that worked.  I am on "use defined encoder", extension ".mp3", pointing to the correct location of lame, used the above encoding options, set bitrate to 224, and selected "delete wav after compression" and "add ID3 tag" only and selected "high quality".

In the offset tab, I have "write freedb id into id3 tag" checked.  In ID3 tab, the first two and the last option are all selected.

If you are getting an error, it has to be that you are not pointing to the correct location of lame.exe, or the lame.exe you have is a bad download.  The one I am using is from rarewares, the "bundle" version.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #8 –
Quote
I don't know what to tell you.  I just tried:
Code: [Select]
-V 2 --vbr-new %s %d
and that worked.  I am on "use defined encoder", extension ".mp3", pointing to the correct location of lame, used the above encoding options, set bitrate to 224, and selected "delete wav after compression" and "add ID3 tag" only and selected "high quality".

In the offset tab, I have "write freedb id into id3 tag" checked.  In ID3 tab, the first two and the last option are all selected.

If you are getting an error, it has to be that you are not pointing to the correct location of lame.exe, or the lame.exe you have is a bad download.  The one I am using is from rarewares, the "bundle" version.
[a href="index.php?act=findpost&pid=354832"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Thanx Hyper.

I am using the exact same settings as you.  I was using the rarewares bundle of LAME.  I tried redownloading it but that shouldn't be the problem as the zip would have been corrupt & I wouldn't have been able 2 extract the lame.exe anyway.

In the DosBox that is opening I have since noticed "file not found" error messages sometimes for the temp wav & sometimes for the renamed wav.  The problem may be my system.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #9 –
The problem might be an incorrect genre from whatever db you're using.  It seems LAME dosent like that, hence why you arent able to encode, but can rip to wavs fine.  The problem that I had with one CD was that it was considered "misc" by freedb and that was not valid.

Just go to Database>edit CD information and pick a fitting genre.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #10 –
Quote from: skywalka on
I am using the recommended settings.

-V 2 --vbr-new --add-id3v2 --pad-id3v2 --ta "%a" --tt "%t" --tl "%g" --ty "%y" --tn "%n" %s %d


Try adding . . .

--ignore-tag-errors

. . . . just a guess.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #11 –
So I just setup a new computer.  I have EAC, LAME, FLAC, etc setup and working well on my old PC.  And BAM I got the same error as below:

Both LAME and FLAC send the error. 

I could not find a final solution in this thread, I did try everything stated.

Quote
---------------------------
Warning
---------------------------
The external compressor returned an error!

Options : -V 2 --vbr-new --add-id3v2 --pad-id3v2 --ta "Sun Don't Shine In The Hood" --tt "The Furious Five" --tl "Raiders Of The Lost Art" --ty "" --tn "02" "C:\Playlist\Raiders Of The Lost Art ()\0tmp660-!.wav" "C:\Playlist\Raiders Of The Lost Art ()\0tmp660-!.mp3"

File : C:\Playlist\Raiders Of The Lost Art ()\02. Sun Don't Shine In The Hood - The Furious Five.wav
---------------------------
OK 
---------------------------

I've been working on this for a whole day.  I do like a challenge but I also like spending my time wisely!

Thanx 4 looking.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #12 –
Quote from: msobetzko on
So I just setup a new computer.  I have EAC, LAME, FLAC, etc setup and working well on my old PC.  And BAM I got the same error as below:

Both LAME and FLAC send the error. 

I could not find a final solution in this thread, I did try everything stated.


In looking at my old system I had version 95.4 installed.  I installed this older version onto my new PC and the MP3 rip was without problem.  The FLAC rip went OK until the last step where EAC renames the converted file to the "proper" song title.  The file stays named based on the temp name EAC gives it.  The file plays well and is tagged.  Very strange.  I believe all these issues revolve around the naming of the file and (in the case of the new releases) the external encoders ability to see the file based on the name.

Any thoughts?

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #13 –
Come on folks.  What am I missing (see above post)

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #14 –
Are you using Vista?
I'm on a horse.
 

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #16 –
Quote from: skywalka on
....when it comes time to compress the files it appears a DOS box is being opened but closing straight away.  I can't see any text within this box but this could be due to lag on my video card or memory.

That dosbox can be opened with alt-tab. It's an action in the background while EAC is ripping another track.
In EAC's statusbar threre is a message about the number of tasks pending

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #17 –
Quote from: collector on
That dosbox can be opened with alt-tab.
Not when it's already finished and returned an error.

@msobetzko and anyone else complaining about this type of error:
You are wasting our time if you don't provide a header from a log file and tell us exactly how you have the External Compression tab in the Compression Options configured.  It seems all you did here was copy and paste what was written by skywalka which wasn't enough information to begin with.  I can't speak for anyone else, but it's gotten to the point where I'm starting to ignore threads rather than ask people to provide more information.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #18 –
Quote from: greynol on
Quote from: collector on
That dosbox can be opened with alt-tab.
Not when it's already finished and returned an error.

@msobetzko and anyone else complaining about this type of error:
You are wasting our time if you don't provide a header from a log file and tell us exactly how you have the External Compression tab in the Compression Options configured.  It seems all you did here was copy and paste what was written by skywalka which wasn't enough information to begin with.  I can't speak for anyone else, but it's gotten to the point where I'm starting to ignore threads rather than ask people to provide more information.



My intent certainly was not to waste your or anyones time.  The OP had the same issue that I have/had so I added to the thread.  It's hard to tell for a novice such as myself, what information is necessary to assist in these situations.

As it turns out, at least for version .95b4 (which I'm happy to continue using), you're request for the log has aided me in solving my problem.  When I went looking (not knowing where to find the log info) in the compression section, I noticed that for my FLAC profile I still had .MP3 as the file extension.  Changing this to .FLAC seems to have worked and now the compressed file is named correctly.

I will not be installing the current EAC version, as I had a whole different degree of problem in that the external processor never returned a functional file (either MP3 of Flac)

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #19 –
Quote from: msobetzko on
My intent certainly was not to waste your or anyones time.  The OP had the same issue that I have/had so I added to the thread.  It's hard to tell for a novice such as myself, what information is necessary to assist in these situations.

Maybe a sticky at the top of the forum would be in order.

With any luck maybe people will read it before asking for help with a ripping or encoding problem.

Glad to see you were able to fix your problem.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #20 –
I was having the same problem.  The genre fix did it for me.  It turns out 'Alternative Rock' is not a valid genre.  It has to be 'Alt. Rock'.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #21 –
I started having this error.

What do I need to post — EAC's log?

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #22 –
Could you provide more info on what you did and how you did it? EAC's log probably won't provide any more information about why an external compressor returned an error.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #23 –
An EAC log will show the program used for compression, the parameter passing scheme as well as exactly what was used for the additional command line options.

EAC: The external compressor returned an error!

Reply #24 –
Look here, that's why I had problems.