IPB

Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

is Ogg Vorbis the best Lossy encoder? (what is?)
snadge
post Jun 8 2011, 04:01
Post #1





Group: Members
Posts: 32
Joined: 5-March 11
From: UK
Member No.: 88709



ive been trying to find out which encoder produces the best audio quality at similar bitrates (say 128k) to other lossy encoders - ive seen a couple of reviews and tests and they seem to point to Ogg Vorbis as being the better encoder - I encoded a WAV file to MP3, AAC, WMA & Vorbis all at 128k CBR and while it was hard to tell any difference the Ogg Vorbis was pumping out higher frequencies at 20Khz + and the rest were up to 18Khz (according to spectrum on Foobar2000)

the only gripe is during conversion Ogg Vorbis was the only one that didnt have the Tag info from the WAV file.

can anyone lead me to more listening test results and the likes so i can ascertain for myself? - i would like others views on "best lossy codec" etc

I read on Wikipedia that AAC at 128k is supposedly Transparent to the lossless source according to listening tests by M-PEG for ITU or something? - I was hoping to adopt AAC as my default rip codec as I have an iPod and MP3 player that plays AAC - but Iam in the market for a new media-player so all this is irrelevant as I can buy something to suite.

thanks in advance for replies smile.gif

please be gentle...im a noob at all this,

This post has been edited by snadge: Jun 8 2011, 04:17


--------------------
www.dslbuddy.net - Broadband Tech Support
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Start new topic
Replies
SonicBooom!
post Jun 8 2011, 04:36
Post #2





Group: Members
Posts: 118
Joined: 16-February 11
Member No.: 88210



I hope I'll not get bashed for I am not truly an expert on this. I haven't tried Ogg Vorbis yet, but if I should choose between AAC (.m4a) and MP3, I would choose MP3. The main reason why is because I apply album gain on all my audio files. To apply album gain to an .m4a file(s), one will use AACgain but upon reading this (from http://altosdesign.com/aacgain/), I thought of reverting back to mp3:
QUOTE
"UNLIKE MP3GAIN, AACGAIN IS NOT COMPLETELY REVERSIBLE. THE UNDO OPTION IS INTENDED TO RESTORE A MUSIC FILE TO BE FUNCTIONALLY EQUIVALENT TO ITS ORIGINAL STATE, BUT IT WILL NOT BE BIT-FOR-BIT IDENTICAL TO THE ORIGINAL FILE. IT IS POSSIBLE FOR APPLE TO CHANGE THE ITUNES MUSIC FILE FORMAT IN WAYS THAT ARE INCOMPATIBLE WITH AACGAIN, RESULTING TO CORRUPTED MUSIC FILES THAT CANNOT BE RESTORED TO THEIR ORIGINAL STATE."

I don't have enough free space on my hard disk to back up everything and time also for maintaining two identical files. To conclude, if you can discern the difference between an MP3/AAC/WMA and Ogg Vorbis by a matter of 2KHz, then go for Vorbis, but if not, then you have another dilemma on choosing which one of the remaining three to choose laugh.gif Goodluck!


--------------------
sin(α) = v sound/v object = Mach No.
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
- snadge   is Ogg Vorbis the best Lossy encoder? (what is?)   Jun 8 2011, 04:01
- - SonicBooom!   I hope I'll not get bashed for I am not truly ...   Jun 8 2011, 04:36
- - snadge   thanks for the info im glad you told me about re...   Jun 8 2011, 04:58
- - terhardp   I'm saying this from my personal view, not bas...   Jun 8 2011, 07:10
|- - snadge   QUOTE (terhardp @ Jun 8 2011, 07:10) I...   Jun 8 2011, 17:32
|- - saratoga   QUOTE (snadge @ Jun 8 2011, 12:32) I play...   Jun 8 2011, 18:52
|- - snadge   QUOTE (saratoga @ Jun 8 2011, 17:52) QUOT...   Jun 9 2011, 14:03
|- - DonP   QUOTE (snadge @ Jun 9 2011, 08:03) [ he i...   Jun 9 2011, 15:26
- - googlebot   What is the best car?   Jun 8 2011, 07:43
|- - Lorem Ipsum   The Batmobile.   Jun 8 2011, 08:07
|- - Cron   QUOTE (googlebot @ Jun 8 2011, 08:43) Wha...   Jun 8 2011, 08:10
- - smok3   if planing to rockbox, i would check battery eatin...   Jun 8 2011, 19:15
- - C.R.Helmrich   @ snadge: regarding quality, have a look at http:/...   Jun 8 2011, 19:45
- - Xanikseo   Regarding that link, it's only really useful f...   Jun 8 2011, 22:03
|- - Canar   QUOTE (Xanikseo @ Jun 8 2011, 14:03) Howe...   Jun 8 2011, 22:56
- - snadge   thanks for all the great replies... so, do you th...   Jun 9 2011, 13:43
- - lvqcl   Dynamics? What is it?   Jun 9 2011, 13:49
|- - snadge   QUOTE (lvqcl @ Jun 9 2011, 12:49) Dynamic...   Jun 9 2011, 13:56
|- - pdq   QUOTE (snadge @ Jun 9 2011, 08:56) QUOTE ...   Jun 9 2011, 14:25
- - Xanikseo   QUOTE (pdq @ Jun 9 2011, 14:25) QUOTE (sn...   Jun 10 2011, 01:00
|- - dv1989   QUOTE (Xanikseo @ Jun 10 2011, 01:00) QUO...   Jun 10 2011, 01:30
- - smok3   QUOTE (DonP @ Jun 9 2011, 16:26) QUOTE (s...   Jun 10 2011, 07:10
|- - DonP   QUOTE (smok3 @ Jun 10 2011, 01:10) QUOTE ...   Jun 10 2011, 12:44
|- - saratoga   QUOTE (smok3 @ Jun 10 2011, 02:10) QUOTE ...   Jun 10 2011, 15:32
- - smok3   saratoga, andless is working with my old musepack ...   Jun 12 2011, 11:02
- - Xanikseo   QUOTE (dv1989 @ Jun 10 2011, 01:30) Quali...   Jun 12 2011, 14:07
|- - saratoga   QUOTE (Xanikseo @ Jun 12 2011, 09:07) Whe...   Jun 12 2011, 18:10
- - dv1989   While your post is considered and doesn’t look par...   Jun 12 2011, 17:16
- - Xanikseo   I do accept that vbr is necessary, music does cons...   Jun 12 2011, 20:08
|- - saratoga   QUOTE (Xanikseo @ Jun 12 2011, 15:08) Whe...   Jun 12 2011, 21:09
- - Xanikseo   I meant what kind of signal would represent a prob...   Jun 13 2011, 00:09
- - [JAZ]   @Xanikseo: While everything is representable by se...   Jun 13 2011, 09:46
|- - saratoga   QUOTE ([JAZ] @ Jun 13 2011, 04:46...   Jun 13 2011, 17:14
- - Xanikseo   I never said that you should use a square waves as...   Jun 15 2011, 23:20
- - K-Meleon   @OP: This test shows that 96 kbps QuickTime AAC is...   Jun 16 2011, 07:25
- - B7k   QUOTE (K-Meleon @ Jun 16 2011, 02:25...   Jun 27 2011, 06:47


Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 



RSS Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 28th July 2014 - 19:31