IPB

Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Why Live-vs-Recorded Listening Tests Don't Work
solive
post Jul 10 2010, 11:08
Post #1





Group: Members
Posts: 162
Joined: 21-February 04
From: Los Angeles
Member No.: 12173



Thomas Edison was probably the greatest stereo salesman that ever lived. He believed that "listeners will hear what you tell them to hear", and he was pretty successful convincing thousands of listeners that his 1910 Edison Diamond Disc Phonograph reproduced recordings that sounded identical to a live performance. His secret weapon was an elaborate live-versus-recorded demonstration that managed to convince people that his phonograph sounded a lot better than it really was.

Several times over the past 10 years, I have been asked by live-versus-recorded apologists why I don't do these types of the tests since they claim they are the only true valid measures of loudspeaker fidelity or accuracy. That is what prompted me to write about why I believe live-versus-recorded listening tests don't work, in this month's blog article

Cheers
Sean Olive
Audio Musings

This post has been edited by solive: Jul 10 2010, 11:30


--------------------
Sean Olive
[url="http://seanolive.com"]Audio Musings[/url]
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Start new topic
Replies
greynol
post Jul 12 2010, 02:26
Post #2





Group: Super Moderator
Posts: 10339
Joined: 1-April 04
From: San Francisco
Member No.: 13167



Unless he can assure us that his opinion about the relative sound quality of a live event cannot possibly be influenced by other factors than just sound quality then he hasn't a leg to stand on.

In case you aren't catching on, Scott, lofty esoteric comments about sound which are not backed by blind testing is generally frowned upon.

This post has been edited by greynol: Jul 12 2010, 02:31


--------------------
Your eyes cannot hear.
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
- solive   Why Live-vs-Recorded Listening Tests Don't Work   Jul 10 2010, 11:08
- - kdo   I have a couple of questions. QUOTE Live and Reco...   Jul 10 2010, 16:53
|- - kdo   QUOTE (kdo @ Jul 10 2010, 17:53) Would it...   Jul 11 2010, 16:25
||- - solive   QUOTE (kdo @ Jul 11 2010, 08:25) QUOTE (k...   Jul 13 2010, 00:43
|||- - kdo   QUOTE (solive @ Jul 13 2010, 01:43) The p...   Jul 13 2010, 01:02
||||- - solive   QUOTE (kdo @ Jul 12 2010, 17:02) QUOTE (s...   Jul 13 2010, 04:09
|||- - Arnold B. Krueger   QUOTE (solive @ Jul 12 2010, 19:43) It is...   Jul 13 2010, 20:26
||- - solive   QUOTE (kdo @ Jul 11 2010, 08:25) QUOTE (k...   Jul 13 2010, 04:53
||- - kdo   QUOTE (solive @ Jul 13 2010, 05:09) Sorry...   Jul 13 2010, 20:10
|- - solive   QUOTE (kdo @ Jul 10 2010, 08:53) I have a...   Jul 12 2010, 06:46
|- - kdo   QUOTE (solive @ Jul 12 2010, 07:46) 1) I ...   Jul 12 2010, 21:25
|- - Arnold B. Krueger   QUOTE (solive @ Jul 12 2010, 01:46) 1) I ...   Jul 13 2010, 17:25
|- - zane9   QUOTE (Arnold B. Krueger @ Jul 13 2010, 11...   Jul 13 2010, 18:50
||- - Arnold B. Krueger   QUOTE (zane9 @ Jul 13 2010, 13:50) QUOTE ...   Jul 13 2010, 20:21
||- - kdo   I sense a big fat TOS-8 violation right here: QUOT...   Jul 14 2010, 02:19
||- - Ed Seedhouse   One form of "live vs. reccorded" test wi...   Jul 14 2010, 02:35
|||- - kdo   QUOTE (Ed Seedhouse @ Jul 14 2010, 03:35)...   Jul 14 2010, 02:57
||- - Arnold B. Krueger   QUOTE (kdo @ Jul 13 2010, 21:19) I sense ...   Jul 14 2010, 03:12
||- - kdo   QUOTE (Arnold B. Krueger @ Jul 14 2010, 04...   Jul 14 2010, 03:30
||- - Arnold B. Krueger   QUOTE (kdo @ Jul 13 2010, 22:30) QUOTE (A...   Jul 14 2010, 10:42
||- - kdo   QUOTE (Arnold B. Krueger @ Jul 14 2010, 11...   Jul 14 2010, 16:56
||- - Arnold B. Krueger   QUOTE (kdo @ Jul 14 2010, 11:56) QUOTE (A...   Jul 14 2010, 17:15
||- - kdo   QUOTE (Arnold B. Krueger @ Jul 14 2010, 18...   Jul 14 2010, 17:58
|- - 2Bdecided   QUOTE (Arnold B. Krueger @ Jul 13 2010, 17...   Jul 14 2010, 19:04
|- - analog scott   QUOTE (2Bdecided @ Jul 14 2010, 19:04) QU...   Jul 14 2010, 20:40
|- - Arnold B. Krueger   QUOTE (2Bdecided @ Jul 14 2010, 14:04) It...   Jul 16 2010, 07:58
|- - 2Bdecided   QUOTE (Arnold B. Krueger @ Jul 16 2010, 07...   Jul 16 2010, 16:29
|- - Arnold B. Krueger   QUOTE (2Bdecided @ Jul 16 2010, 11:29) Cr...   Jul 16 2010, 23:59
- - analog scott   QUOTE (solive @ Jul 10 2010, 12:08) Thoma...   Jul 10 2010, 18:41
|- - solive   QUOTE (analog scott @ Jul 10 2010, 10:41)...   Jul 11 2010, 07:46
|- - analog scott   QUOTE (solive @ Jul 11 2010, 07:46) What ...   Jul 11 2010, 15:50
|- - googlebot   QUOTE (analog scott @ Jul 11 2010, 16:50)...   Jul 11 2010, 16:53
||- - analog scott   QUOTE (googlebot @ Jul 11 2010, 16:53) QU...   Jul 11 2010, 17:44
||- - aclo   QUOTE (googlebot @ Jul 11 2010, 17:53) Wh...   Jul 12 2010, 04:06
|- - solive   QUOTE (analog scott @ Jul 11 2010, 07:50)...   Jul 11 2010, 20:16
||- - analog scott   QUOTE (solive @ Jul 11 2010, 21:16) QUOTE...   Jul 11 2010, 20:33
||- - googlebot   QUOTE (solive @ Jul 11 2010, 21:16) The r...   Jul 11 2010, 20:33
|||- - solive   QUOTE (googlebot @ Jul 11 2010, 12:33) QU...   Jul 12 2010, 06:19
||- - 2Bdecided   QUOTE (solive @ Jul 11 2010, 20:16) The r...   Jul 14 2010, 18:54
|- - greynol   QUOTE (analog scott @ Jul 11 2010, 07:50)...   Jul 11 2010, 20:28
|- - Notat   QUOTE (greynol @ Jul 11 2010, 13:28) It...   Jul 11 2010, 23:06
- - greynol   Quite unfortunate if someone wants to garner somet...   Jul 11 2010, 23:19
- - greynol   Unless he can assure us that his opinion about the...   Jul 12 2010, 02:26
- - greynol   analogscott's post binned per TOS #2. Further...   Jul 12 2010, 03:09


Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 



RSS Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 27th December 2014 - 01:24