IPB

Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Pre-Test thread, for the 64kbps test
rjamorim
post Aug 22 2003, 07:52
Post #1


Rarewares admin


Group: Members
Posts: 7515
Joined: 30-September 01
From: Brazil
Member No.: 81



Hello.

As most of you already know, I am planning to start a 64kbps public listening test in September.

So here are the planned details. Nothing is definitive so far:

The test starts at September 3rd and ends at September 14th

The codecs that will be tested are:
- Ahead HE-AAC "Streaming :: Medium" VBR profile, high quality.
- Ogg Vorbis post-1.0 CVS -q 0
- MP3pro codec in Adobe Audition, VBR quality 35, high quality, m/s and is stereo, no CRC, no narrowing.
- WMAv9 Standard 64kbps (there's no PRO version at such bitrate, AFAIK)
- Real Audio Cook 64kbps (I didn't investigate other settings yet. Comments welcome)

The samples that will be tested have been announced on this thread. If you have concerns/comments about the sample suite choice, please post there.

The test results will be calculated the same way my former tests were. I don't plan to include bitrates in the formula. Comments are welcome now (they are of no use to me after the test has been started).

I haven't decided about anchors yet (my guru is traveling dry.gif), but someone suggested me that I use Lame ABR 128 as higher anchor, so that we can verify which one of these codecs really deliver the marketing of "sounds like MP3 at half the bitrate" biggrin.gif

Then, the lower anchor would be a standard 3.5kHz lowpass, like it is done on most formal tests at low bitrates.

So, I'd like to know your thoughts on what I planned.

Thanks for your attention;

Roberto.

This post has been edited by rjamorim: Aug 22 2003, 07:53


--------------------
Get up-to-date binaries of Lame, AAC, Vorbis and much more at RareWares:
http://www.rarewares.org
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Start new topic
Replies
tigre
post Aug 22 2003, 17:47
Post #2


Moderator


Group: Members
Posts: 1434
Joined: 26-November 02
Member No.: 3890



QUOTE (rjamorim @ Aug 22 2003, 07:59 AM)
QUOTE
What about ATRAC 3 Plus (Net MD)? Should be interesting IMO.


Hrm... I don't know. Does it implement m/s or IS stereo? (Atrac3 doesn't)

I suggested ATRAC3Plus because it seems to perform quite well at 64kbps at www.soundexpert.info listening test so far - and it has similar hardware support as Ogg Vorbis ATM. ph34r.gif

The most detailed technical description I could find are here and here.

Seems like the newest big improvement is the use of dynamic bit allocation between channels (full stereo, no m/s or is) instead of double mono. laugh.gif

As this format is even more closed than WMA (no plugins for encoders/players available etc.) and hardware players are (and will be) only available by one company I'd say it's a waste of resources to include it in the test.


--------------------
Let's suppose that rain washes out a picnic. Who is feeling negative? The rain? Or YOU? What's causing the negative feeling? The rain or your reaction? - Anthony De Mello
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
- rjamorim   Pre-Test thread   Aug 22 2003, 07:52
- - elmar3rd   I wonder if mp3PRO VBR is reliable. FhG fastenc VB...   Aug 22 2003, 09:13
- - tigre   QUOTE (rjamorim @ Aug 21 2003, 10:52 PM)The c...   Aug 22 2003, 09:16
- - tigre   QUOTE (elmar3rd @ Aug 22 2003, 12:13 AM)I won...   Aug 22 2003, 09:22
- - elmar3rd   Beat me, but what about MP3 (LAME or fastenc) at 6...   Aug 22 2003, 09:38
- - askoff   Is it possible to have QuickTime AAC files also in...   Aug 22 2003, 11:17
- - LadFromDownUnder   With regard to the WMA codec (you are correct that...   Aug 22 2003, 11:44
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (elmar3rd @ Aug 22 2003, 05:13 AM)I won...   Aug 22 2003, 16:59
- - bond   thanks for this test rjamorim! as vorbis 1.0....   Aug 22 2003, 17:44
- - tigre   QUOTE (rjamorim @ Aug 22 2003, 07:59 AM)QUOTE...   Aug 22 2003, 17:47
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (bond @ Aug 22 2003, 01:44 PM)as vorbis...   Aug 23 2003, 03:06
- - kotrtim   QUOTE (rjamorim @ Aug 21 2003, 10:52 PM)WMAv9...   Aug 23 2003, 03:43
- - Dibrom   QUOTE (tigre @ Aug 22 2003, 01:16 AM)What kee...   Aug 23 2003, 03:44
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (tigre @ Aug 22 2003, 01:47 PM)I sugges...   Aug 23 2003, 03:48
- - Canar   QUOTE (Dibrom @ Aug 22 2003, 06:44 PM)As Robe...   Aug 23 2003, 04:36
- - wildboar   QUOTE (Canar @ Aug 22 2003, 09:36 PM)The test...   Aug 23 2003, 05:01
- - Dibrom   QUOTE (Canar @ Aug 22 2003, 08:36 PM)QUOTE (D...   Aug 23 2003, 05:05
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (Canar @ Aug 23 2003, 12:36 AM)This see...   Aug 23 2003, 05:09
- - Canar   @wildboar: The multi-pass ABR method I described w...   Aug 23 2003, 06:09
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (Canar @ Aug 23 2003, 02:09 AM)I think ...   Aug 23 2003, 06:17
- - den   QUOTE Atrac3 won't be a good option. It doesn...   Aug 23 2003, 08:33
- - tigre   QUOTE (Dibrom @ Aug 22 2003, 06:44 PM)I don...   Aug 23 2003, 08:38
- - S_O   For Real Gecko Audio you should use the "64 k...   Aug 23 2003, 11:18
- - guruboolez   Some comments : atrac3plus would be nice to test...   Aug 23 2003, 12:54
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (den @ Aug 23 2003, 04:33 AM)Umm sorry,...   Aug 23 2003, 16:17
- - phong   I think a 64kbps test is going to be less tiring t...   Aug 23 2003, 17:45
- - Dologan   Hmm... I frankly don't understand the ABR/CBR/...   Aug 23 2003, 18:40
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (dologan @ Aug 23 2003, 02:40 PM)A sugg...   Aug 24 2003, 01:01
- - guruboolez   Testing eight different files for each sample does...   Aug 24 2003, 01:14
- - rjamorim   That really sounds like a great idea to me. (Alt...   Aug 24 2003, 01:41
- - guruboolez   Is it worth to put two different anchors in this t...   Aug 24 2003, 01:59
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (guruboolez @ Aug 23 2003, 09:59 PM)Is ...   Aug 24 2003, 02:51
- - ErikS   One idea how to add more codecs to the test would ...   Aug 24 2003, 03:56
- - tigre   Would it be an option to use the 8 sliders for tes...   Aug 24 2003, 07:47
- - S_O   QUOTE That's not a real possibility because, o...   Aug 24 2003, 12:14
- - bond   dont think that people will get bored if they test...   Aug 24 2003, 19:37
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (ErikS @ Aug 23 2003, 11:56 PM)One idea...   Aug 24 2003, 20:02
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (S_O @ Aug 24 2003, 08:14 AM)If they do...   Aug 24 2003, 20:10
- - Gecko   I think dividing the test into an essential and a ...   Aug 24 2003, 20:42
- - S_O   QUOTE Well, is HE AAC, WMA, and Real even "cu...   Aug 24 2003, 21:20
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (S_O @ Aug 24 2003, 05:20 PM)But I noti...   Aug 24 2003, 21:31
- - S_O   QUOTE Well, I believe few would allow a stranger t...   Aug 24 2003, 21:57
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (S_O @ Aug 24 2003, 05:57 PM)You donīt ...   Aug 24 2003, 22:23
- - Dologan   Roberto, are you sure you can't merge the resu...   Aug 25 2003, 05:34
- - rjamorim   Well, the biggest problem I see here is using ff12...   Aug 25 2003, 05:47
- - Dologan   Hmm... I see... When are you planning to start th...   Aug 25 2003, 06:34
- - Gabriel   *I think that Guru's idea of 2 sets is interes...   Aug 25 2003, 08:10
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (dologan @ Aug 25 2003, 02:34 AM)When a...   Aug 25 2003, 08:55
- - rjamorim   QUOTE *I think that Guru's idea of 2 sets is i...   Aug 25 2003, 09:01
- - ErikS   * If someone modifies ff123's tool you use for...   Aug 25 2003, 11:17
- - tigre   QUOTE (rjamorim @ Aug 25 2003, 12:01 AM)QUOTE...   Aug 25 2003, 12:16
- - phong   Another problem with using lame as an anchor is th...   Aug 25 2003, 12:48
- - elmar3rd   In statistics, an anchor can be a middle value, no...   Aug 25 2003, 14:48
- - rjamorim   I think we're making a mess out of this test.....   Aug 25 2003, 17:47
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (tigre @ Aug 25 2003, 08:16 AM)A soluti...   Aug 25 2003, 17:52
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (askoff @ Aug 22 2003, 07:17 AM)EDIT: A...   Aug 25 2003, 18:02
- - tigre   QUOTE Well, as already explained somewhere, the An...   Aug 25 2003, 18:28
- - phong   Ok, these are my personal feelings: I think that ...   Aug 25 2003, 18:52
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (phong @ Aug 25 2003, 02:52 PM)I think ...   Aug 25 2003, 20:48
- - Gabriel   Real: I think that it is not needed wma: I think t...   Aug 26 2003, 08:08
- - Digga   QUOTE (Gabriel @ Aug 25 2003, 11:08 PM)If an ...   Aug 26 2003, 09:50
- - Digga   uups, double post...   Aug 26 2003, 09:50
- - LadFromDownUnder   Roberto, given the MS claims about WMA9 (not WMA8)...   Aug 26 2003, 11:06
- - rjamorim   OK, so let's try this: -HE AAC -Vorbis -MP3pr...   Aug 26 2003, 17:36
- - Digga   That combination looks realy good. This way - you...   Aug 26 2003, 19:45
- - elmar3rd   I agree. Of course, 8 codecs will take some time ...   Aug 26 2003, 19:51
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (Digga @ Aug 26 2003, 03:45 PM)I realy ...   Aug 26 2003, 19:57
- - rjamorim   BTW, some more questions that need to be answered:...   Aug 26 2003, 20:02
- - music_man_mpc   QUOTE (rjamorim @ Aug 26 2003, 11:02 AM)IMO, ...   Aug 26 2003, 20:08
- - phong   The list looks good from where I'm standing. ...   Aug 26 2003, 20:22
- - n68   Ciao... read @ the portal. sounds familiar.: *gen...   Aug 26 2003, 20:26
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (n68 @ Aug 26 2003, 04:26 PM)read @ the...   Aug 26 2003, 20:29
- - phong   Huh?   Aug 26 2003, 21:52
- - brett   rj -- as for which aac to include, i would hate to...   Aug 27 2003, 00:59
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (brett @ Aug 26 2003, 08:59 PM)rj -- as...   Aug 27 2003, 01:12
- - Digga   QUOTE i would hate to see you choose ahead just be...   Aug 27 2003, 01:14
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (Digga @ Aug 26 2003, 09:14 PM)I though...   Aug 27 2003, 01:36
- - Gabriel   For mp3-64m I think that blade would be less inter...   Aug 27 2003, 09:04
- - tigre   QUOTE (rjamorim @ Aug 26 2003, 04:12 PM)I don...   Aug 27 2003, 14:41
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (Gabriel @ Aug 27 2003, 05:04 AM)Using ...   Aug 27 2003, 14:50
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (tigre @ Aug 27 2003, 10:41 AM)- Is it ...   Aug 27 2003, 14:58
- - AstralStorm   I'll do a test with ABC/HR on few of samples f...   Aug 27 2003, 15:22
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (AstralStorm @ Aug 27 2003, 11:22 AM)I...   Aug 27 2003, 15:43
- - ErikS   QUOTE (rjamorim @ Aug 27 2003, 02:58 PM)QUOTE...   Aug 27 2003, 15:48
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (ErikS @ Aug 27 2003, 11:48 AM)Que? I w...   Aug 27 2003, 15:51
- - AstralStorm   Rjamorim, you are hereby granted the rights to us...   Aug 27 2003, 15:55
- - AstralStorm   ABC/HR 0.9b doesn't save the results when I tr...   Aug 27 2003, 17:05
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (AstralStorm @ Aug 27 2003, 01:05 PM)Do...   Aug 27 2003, 17:08
- - AstralStorm   Don't forget to enable all additional options ...   Aug 27 2003, 17:21
- - tigre   QUOTE (rjamorim @ Aug 27 2003, 05:58 AM)QUOTE...   Aug 27 2003, 17:34
- - tigre   Results Settings used: <samplename>_CEP_dev...   Aug 28 2003, 01:08
- - tigre   Next result: The Chopin Piano sample. To me surpri...   Aug 28 2003, 12:18
- - Ivan Dimkovic   Hmm.. for plain AAC (not HE AAC) I think that Ahe...   Aug 28 2003, 13:54
- - AstralStorm   Weird... for me LAME Polonaise sample is just unli...   Aug 28 2003, 14:45
- - tigre   QUOTE (Ivan Dimkovic @ Aug 28 2003, 04:54 AM)...   Aug 28 2003, 17:26
- - rjamorim   I guess the biggest problem of lame vs. FhG is for...   Aug 28 2003, 18:15
- - tigre   Not yet. good idea ...   Aug 28 2003, 18:26
- - askoff   rjamorim: Didn't you say that you are looking ...   Aug 29 2003, 11:27
- - tigre   Results Settings used: <samplename>.wav.wa...   Aug 29 2003, 11:37
- - rjamorim   QUOTE (tigre @ Aug 29 2003, 07:37 AM)Conclusi...   Aug 29 2003, 17:24
2 Pages V   1 2 >


Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 



RSS Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 29th August 2014 - 12:05